Making Public comments FS section

[mikey]

I don't think its fair if comments can be posted in the FS Forum. If someone is selling a watch for thousands or a band, comments that are not in favor of the item should not be posted. If you have your thoughts on whether the item is popular or not should be sent to the seller via PM only. Some people are actually trying to conduct real business here. Comments good/bad interfere with the integrity of the sale:bartmoon: .

[roadcarver]

Shouldn't this be posted in the comments/complaints section?

Was there anybody who commented on your recent sale Mikey? I thought this was already straightened out clearly by the mods, especially with the sticky note in place for the FS section.

[mikey]

I read comments on someone selling a watch, and read a bunch of comments that would turn me off as a potential buyer. I am not naming anyone but comments should be removed from the FS that challenge the integrity of the sale. I am just making a point, and not trying to point out anyone in particular. I probably should have posted in the complaints section, so I hope this thread is moved there. I just want selling things fair.

[walds11]

I completely agree Mikey. That stuff is not tolerated on others forums.

[mikey]

Wald, its like trying to sell a house. You get your potential buyers by appointment and they call you if they are interested or want to make an offer. Even if they got negative comments, they let you know in private. Otherwise, its not fair to publicly let others know what you like or don't like. Selling Rolex items is just the same as real estate. You got your customer that you don't have to convince and you got your skeptics. Its cool. I got potential buyers that I send pics and describe and they say yay or nay. Thats life.

[padi56]

I don't think its fair if comments can be posted in the FS Forum. If someone is selling a watch for thousands or a band, comments that are not in favor of the item should not be posted. If you have your thoughts on whether the item is popular or not should be sent to the seller via PM only. Some people are actually trying to conduct real business here. Comments good/bad interfere with the integrity of the sale:bartmoon: .
Moved to the correct forum
Well Mikey I have had a look in the for-sale forum, and I cannot find one single posting.That has been posted after we mods and admin,put a few rules in the posting of Responses in the For Sale Threads forum.And think below link fully covers your above posting,so this topic and thread is closed.

http://www.rolexforums.com/showthread.php?t=12058

Shouldn't this be posted in the comments/complaints section?

Was there anybody who commented on your recent sale Mikey? I thought this was already straightened out clearly by the mods, especially with the sticky note in place for the FS section.

Thank you Vernon you have read the new Responses in the For Sale Threads rules