Great question and I’m not surprised to see opinions split down the middle as they’re both great watches.
I’ve purchased both in the last month from my London AD and can say without question that i prefer the Pepsi on Jubilee, which I did not expect as the Batman on Oyster has been on my mind for almost 10 years now lol
The main reasons for this are often down to the fact that I have the new Submariner and therefore the BLNR is actually too similar. The bezel is very subtle so often looks black and the PCL on Oyster picks up scratches immediately 🫣 ( I mean , how clothing scratches steal is beyond me lol )
The BLRO is a totally different look with the bezel colours being much more vibrant and Jubilee, not only being more dressy, but also hides the scratches perfectly so ironically can be worn more often than the Oyster if that thing bothers you.
I’ll wear the Submariner daily and save the BLRO for nicer occasions including using as my ‘dress watch’ .
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk