I was weighing up both too having recently seen them both.
The 5236P is a very simple and clean dial automatic at 42mm. 5270P is manual PCC, busier dial but stealth white metal, felt it had the edge over 5270J for me.
So ordered the 5270P intending it to be a daily wearer as far as possible. 5370P another level again in horological feature but less useful daily
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk