My logic: Someone earlier wrote it's a classic case of "he said, she said" and nailed it.
By the end of the day this isn't an oversight from Robert or her but one or the other side has deliberately pulled off a nasty scam. This got me thinking why (motive). Then it clicked: False sense of entitlement. Yup, guilty as charged. She did it again and it is her false sense of entitlement !!! First the fake headlights and now a timepiece she can't afford. Tsk.
Seriously, I hope someone nails her and this works out for you Robert. Good luck.