Funny how time changes perspective and perceptions, 3-5 yrs ago the 5712 was favored 2 to1 over the 5711.
I however liked the clean look of the 5711, maybe because the 5712 was like Big Foot, hard to see or find. So I got a 5711
I was able to get a 5712 and another 5711 3 1/2 years ago when ADs needed cash $$.
While the 5711 photos well and looks good in both my versions, the 5712 dial is Magical. I have not worn any other in almost 3 years. I had to pull them out after finding this forum on a lark the other day.
I had the same belief that the 5712 was unbalanced, asymmetrical, yada,yada.
but on the wrist, the magic takes over! And unlike any other Nautilus dial there are no cut outs!
I had the 5980 for a few days before I sent it back, while nice it was to bulky for me, and I'm not a chronograph guy. %726 doesn't appeal to me.
Its been awhile since I've taken watch pics, I'll do better next time :)