I like them both, and have tried on both, though I own neither. I've been strongly considering this AP, and have received some excellent owner reviews, along with several others who say that they either didn't like the bracelet (hair puller), didn't like the minute hand moving when they set the time, or both. Two have since moved to the Vacheron Overseas. I had the AP on my wrist last week, and found it to be a gorgeous watch.
As far as the Aquanaut is concerned, everything I've read from owners is that they love the watch. It's quite stunning on the wrist.
You've put yourself in an enviable position, and could well end up with both.
