IMHO there should be a new "3 strikes and you're out" Policy for all those "Wise-guy" members out there making comments like "looks like a Replica " or "definitely fake" or "terrible dial" without any explanation and/or justification whatsoever, then they turn out to be completely wrong. When asked why they gave that incorrect opinion - they are suddenly "gone with the Wind" ... it seems completely counter-productive not to mention giving the OP the completely wrong impression ...just my 2 cents ...