Quote:
Originally Posted by aj_tucker
Hi all,
I'm debating between two 5170s; the P ($85kUSD) and the white-dialed G ($45k). I've been drooling over the P for months and have heard the impassioned pleas of contributors here that the P is the end all, be all of the 5170. I finally saw them both side-by-side at Michael Ashton in NYC yesterday. But, the closer I get to pulling the trigger, I'm leaning G...Here's some rationale.
The P is objectively a far more beautiful watch, truly one of the best looking pieces I've ever seen. But, it's VERY dressy and I would argue that strap changes won't affect that much. My sense is I'd own it, worship it, but reach for it maybe once or twice a month. I work in tech and almost never wear a suit.
The G, while more plain, is more wearable. The Breguet numerals give the dial some warmth, and it's a strap monster. Seems like it could easily be dressed up or down.
Summarily, I think I lust after the P but the G would give more long term ownership satisfaction.
My collection is small (I have a 1803 Day Date, 1680, and a 116500LN), and this is my first Patek. Truthfully, I might have to sell the Daytona to afford the P. At my income level, $85k is a great deal to allocate to one watch that I think, despite it being the most beautiful watch I've ever seen, won't wear as much. Still...it's so stunningly gorgeous.
My questions are these:
- 5170P or G owners: do you wear the watch often? Does it look harmonious with a variety of dress colors and styles?
- Is it better to own the best possible piece and not wear it or get more use out of something that is a little less desirable but more flexible?
|
I wouldn't sell the Daytona. Since you mentioned the price and having to sell your Daytona... If your income level doesn't permit you to buy a $45k or $85k watch without selling something, I think it's probably a purchase that may be out of proportion to your current finances. I think a good amount of people here, as someone else mentioned, have $300k+ collections. Their advice as to which to get is likely not bound by any financial constraints. I feel like owning an $85k watch wouldn't be fun unless I knew that it was money I didn't need (i.e., F___ Y__ money). In any case, the price difference between the two buys a lot of watch. Do you like the P more than the G, plus your Daytona, and a royal oak (or whatever floats your boat)?
I would end up resenting a purchase of that level that I didn't wear often (as you suggested you might not), especially if I ended up selling a solid daily classic (the daytona) to get it and tied up a good chunk of change. This is all my personal opinion, so take it with a grain of salt as I obviously don't know your personal situation. Best of luck!