OP 36 vs 41: you decide

[Cru Jones]

Thanks for the thoughts.

For me, there is something about the 36 that looks really well balanced.

On dial alone (which is that photo), I think the 36 is the clear winner. But I see most comments focused on wrist size…..

Thinking about the overall package, given the all brushed bracelet, the 41 might be the overall better package for someone like me who is 2 meters tall. Make it the yellow one as part of a collection for fun.

Originally Posted by espanol

I prefer the classic size of 36mm. I actually think it would look best on most. The 41 (while wearing closer to 40), IMO, leaves too much empty space on the dial.

That’s how I feel with the side by side photo. Maybe in real life it’s different? Sad thing with Rolex these days, maybe I’ll never know.

Originally Posted by Dougiebaby

Depends on wrist size. HOWEVER, there is one aspect of the 36 I much prefer over the 41...

The batons on the 36 have a beveled edge whereas the 41's have no bevel. The light play and added level of refinement of the 36 wins if one can fit either watch.

That’s interesting, I hadn’t noticed that before.

Originally Posted by noshame

Looks alone, the 36 dial is more pleasing, but in the end it'll depend on wrist size and how it fits on the wearer. Also, is the goal a sportier look or more classic look? That will affect the choice as well.

This could be an easy way to make the choice: classic/vintage or sporty? Thanks.

Originally Posted by harvey

Cru, I’ve tried both OP sizes on, even for slightly smaller wrists…the 41 looked better.

I would love to try them both on. Thanks for the report.

Originally Posted by Krash

The poll is sort of meaningless. It's all about wrist size. For some people, the 36 is the right answer. For others, the 41 is the right answer.

Not exactly the purpose of the poll….

Originally Posted by brandrea

I’m not the right person to ask in that I can never see “proportions” like others seem to

That said, on your wrist you could go either way. I have a feeling you’d find the 41 more to your liking since you are used to Panerai and your LVC.

For me, I’d go 41mm and green dial

Thanks Brian. You are probably right about which size would be best for me. Although a yellow 36 could have the visual punch while also giving greater variety with size.

And you are definitely right that the green 41 would be great for you!

BTW, it’s your “fault” I even started looking at these due to your idea in a separate thread of a dark blue 41 OP.

[Rags]

I prefer watches between 36mm & 39mm for dress watches. IMO anything bigger than 40mm is too big for me.

[matthew P]

I prefer the 36 for the beveled markers and the relative size of the case V the bracelet ….. to me it’s more as their ally pleasing.

As far as wrist sizes go I’m in agreement….. greater than 7.5/ 41mm….. less than 6.5 / 36mm.
The 6.5 to 7.5 crowd gets to choose the sportier look or the dressier sizing


….Save the drama - I’m just here for the photos….

[MJZRolex]

The pink 36 certainly isn't small on the wrist shown above. I think a 41 on that wrist would be overwhelming. I have a 6.5" flat wrist and the 36 would be a much better fit for me, but I have no problem with the look of the Submariner 40 mm on my wrist. If I got the call, I'd definitely give the 41 a try.

[mmalek1]

I have the 36mm green, but I wish I had the 41mm instead. I have approx 7inch wrist

[Golfbone]

39 is the ideal size.

[eijiboy]

Originally Posted by dpt.calvin

36 all day for you. Even that looks large. 41 would be silly IMO.

Yeah. Agree. It looks right but doesnt feel right due to weight. Very light compare to sub. On pictures looks good.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[eijiboy]

Originally Posted by EEpro

Your crown is unscrewed.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Yeah i was adjusting the time.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[zhanhui913]

36mm is my preferred size.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[Oyster Sauce]

Originally Posted by thenewrick

My thinking is under 7 inch wrist go 36mm. Over 7.5 inch wrist is 40+mm.

I’m glad I’m a large man with large wrists, around 7.5-7.75) but I wish I had the smaller wrists just to easily wear the 34-36mm references.

Smaller wristed people are really screwing themselves over by holding out for oversized references when 34-36 are cheaper and more available.

I think both look balanced and equal. No preference.

+1

[thenewrick]

I can confirm the OP41 Silver yellow gold indices are beveled. Not sure about the standard white gold applique on the other references though.

If they aren't beveled on the standard white gold indices that would be interesting. I know the yellow gold applique is unique for the reference so maybe they did a little something extra for it too. It is the reference they marquee on their website and most advertising for the new OP lineup. I think it was supposed to be their halo reference for the new range before the "Tiffany" blue blew up.

[Driver8]

With 7.75" wrists, the 41mm is the only way I'd go.

[2nastie]

Funny how it seems like 41 would be "more ideal" but when it comes down to the Explorer 1 39mm it suddenly becomes a bit more controversial and the people rave about the 36mm.

[Driver8]

Originally Posted by 2nastie

Funny how it seems like 41 would be "more ideal" but when it comes done to the Explorer 1 39mm it suddenly becomes a bit more controversial and the people rave about the 36mm.

Good observation.

Personally speaking I think it's a real shame the 39mm Explorer was discontinued as I much prefer it over the 36mm, but I never managed to pick one up.

[thenewrick]

Wouldn't be surprised at all to see a 39-40-41mm Explorer introduced at some point. Might be waiting on the new Airking case

[JSCP]

Pick the one you like

I’d
pick 41 as the 41mm wears smaller than you think

[MJ EXPLORER]

I'm pleasantly surprised how the 36 has held its own.

I voted 36!

[Gaijin]

Originally Posted by EEpro

Double batons. I'm out.

[Gaijin]

Originally Posted by Golfbone

39 is the ideal size.

Goldilocks size.

[LoanLOL]

Originally Posted by thenewrick

I can confirm the OP41 Silver yellow gold indices are beveled. Not sure about the standard white gold applique on the other references though.

If they aren't beveled on the standard white gold indices that would be interesting. I know the yellow gold applique is unique for the reference so maybe they did a little something extra for it too. It is the reference they marquee on their website and most advertising for the new OP lineup. I think it was supposed to be their halo reference for the new range before the "Tiffany" blue blew up.

So they are on the other dials ! It's actually quite difficult to see but they reflect the light beautifully

[1William]

The 41.

[GST15]

Originally Posted by thenewrick

I can confirm the OP41 Silver yellow gold indices are beveled. Not sure about the standard white gold applique on the other references though.

If they aren't beveled on the standard white gold indices that would be interesting. I know the yellow gold applique is unique for the reference so maybe they did a little something extra for it too. It is the reference they marquee on their website and most advertising for the new OP lineup. I think it was supposed to be their halo reference for the new range before the "Tiffany" blue blew up.

The Silver 41 OP is the best looking of the lot IMHO

[samson66]

41 but really wrist dependent

[GST15]

As stated above, depends on wrist size, as well as use. I have a 36 DJ that I usually wear for dress or business casual. I have an OP 41 that I wear as more of a sports watch. (7in wrist)

[rmlovett1]

I think they both look great! My wrist size is 6.75 and I prefer to wear 39-44mm depending on the watch. I have a 36mm and I’ll wear it for certain occasions, but I think it looks small.
As I’ve stated many times….the size of the watch looking good, isn’t / shouldn’t be, based on the wrist size alone.
There’s too many other factors….general fashion choice, body type, forearm size, in my case…a tattooed hand/arm.
I mean….I respect and couldn’t care less if a gentleman wants to wear a 31-36mm pink OP, that’s their prerogative, and more power to them. It would just look kind of odd on me. IMO
All personal choices…go with whatever makes you happy!