Stretch on band of Rolex watch not disclosed by seller on eBay

[jdnally]

Hi Everyone,

I just wanted you opinion. I bought a 1973 Rolex Datejust from a seller from Japan. Everything checked out and it came with a Rolex certificate. My issue is that the seller didn't disclose the stretch on the band. I was cleaning the watch yesterday and one of the links broke in half. I took it to my jeweler and he said the band is really old and is on its last leg. It will cost $40 to remove the broken link and reattach and there is no guarantee that it won't break anyday. So I opted to replace the band with one from this brand called Spiedel.

I don't really want to return the watch to Japan. Should I contact the seller to ask for a partial refund? If so, what is a good amount? The watch plus shipping cost me $1,870.00 and the replacement band is probably about $50.00. The original band is basically useless, but of course I will keep it.

Any input will be much appreciated. Thanks!

Jdnally

[crowncollection]

hi, an original replacement band is more like $1000 new if steel, and at least $400 for a good used one, you do not state if the watch is steel or two tone, so i pressume its steel since you quote an aftermarket one is 50 dollars only and a two tone band even aftermarket is more than that due to the price of gold.

[jdnally]

Thanks for your reply. I shouldn't say aftermarket, but a generic brand (Speidel). Anyway, I got desperate and had my jeweler install a generic band for me just so I can wear the Rolex watch. The seller reimbursed me $50 for my trouble. I didn't want to return the watch to Japan as I was afraid it would get lost in transit and I would be completely at a loss. A 1973 datejust two tone with generic band for around $1800 is not bad, right? It was serviced and in almost excellent condition.

[mikkolopez]

That seems fair. Enjoy the watch and if ever you go for the real band, it will just make the watch more enjoyable.

[floater156]

Yikes!