Add SD43 or Redundant? Pics included

[chad362wiley]

Thinking about adding an SD43 to this mix. Whatcha think. Too redundant? Would be paying a premium but not a crazy one. At this price a skydweller is pretty close as well. I'm more concerned with loss on resale as I cannot try any of these pieces on before I buy them, so i dont want to get waxed should i not like it and have to resell.

Advice welcome, thanks

[Atom4]

Not in my opinion. I have a Sub C and I'm considering getting a SD43 (if I can find one at retail).

[Hank]

I would rather add a Daytona C instead of the SD43.

[DocHorton]

Not redundant at all....black bezel, black dial, 43mm, and brushed bracelet. Totally different look than any you have.

[SeaDweller50]

Would never pay a premium with that collection.

[JacksonStone]

There's no right or wrong on this one. My opinion is it's redundant, but I'm the kind of person who, already having a SubC, won't buy another Sub or GMT, because I find them too similar. Others just love the Rolex diver/sports model look, and can't get enough of it.

So, as always, ask the little man inside you, because he knows all. None of us can tell you.

[chad362wiley]

Originally Posted by Hank

I would rather add a Daytona C instead of the SD43.

Had a black one and sold it, really wanted white. the premiums are just astronomical.

Originally Posted by Ra_88

Would never pay a premium with that collection.

this is a good point. My dealer could do MSRP no tax but it would tax 4-6 months. I have no issue waiting

[morimotom]

It’s closest to the hulk in appearance, but it’s still not close.

Get the 43.

[topfuel25]

43 is losing steam slowly

[SeaDweller50]

It would certainly be a great addition to the collection, that’s for sure. Definitely worth waiting and getting your name on the card imo.

[Helmi]

Get it...it is different enough from the other watches. Great collection

[Rolex.c6]

Not at all if you ask me. It's a beauty, get it if you can. Very good collection btw.

[Watcheroo]

Originally Posted by chad362wiley

this is a good point. My dealer could do MSRP no tax but it would tax 4-6 months. I have no issue waiting

If you decide to add it, I’d definitely wait the 4-6 months to get it from my AD.

For me though, given your collection, the SD43 covers the same bases as a couple you already have. I’d spend my money on something else. No mistake that it’s a great watch though

[Devildog]

Much as the SD43 is my favourite Rolex of all time, if I were you I’d get the Sky D. It’s a fantastic watch and would round off your collection -

2 different divers
2 different multiple time zones
One dressier AP.

[peterpl]

You have a nice collection mate of sports models.

Get something with fluted bezel. (i.e) A skydweller or a DD40

[peterpl]

You have a nice collection mate of sports models.

Get something with fluted bezel. (i.e) A skydweller or a DD40

[SeaDweller50]

Originally Posted by topfuel25

43 is losing steam slowly

Indeed. I’m sure they’ll start to appear in AD windows before you know it.

[HL65]

Add it it’s a great watch and not redundant at all!

[liuk3]

Get it if you want it. Nice watch.

[V25V]

I have 3/4 of those, 15300 blue, blnr and hulk, just got a SD43. So...not in my opinion.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk Pro

[samson66]

Judging from your photos, I think the SD43 might wear a little large on you.

[travisb]

Would fit in nicely.

[Watch Admirer]

add

[JohnnyRol]

Originally Posted by Devildog

Much as the SD43 is my favourite Rolex of all time, if I were you I’d get the Sky D. It’s a fantastic watch and would round off your collection -

2 different divers
2 different multiple time zones
One dressier AP.

I tend to agree with this and I have an SD43 and love it. I blue Sky Dweller would fit in nicely. BUT it would not be a mistake to get it. Being patient and waiting for a AD to get without a premium and have your name on papers would be best in the long run.

[Flybak]

SD43 is a great option and not redundant given your collection but if you can actually choose a Sky D as an alternative, it's definitely more complementary and would be a better way to round out the lineup.

[AK797]

Originally Posted by Devildog

Much as the SD43 is my favourite Rolex of all time, if I were you I’d get the Sky D. It’s a fantastic watch and would round off your collection -

2 different divers
2 different multiple time zones
One dressier AP.

I'm the same, in isolation I prefer the SD43 but not here.

[AK797]

Originally Posted by samson66

Judging from your photos, I think the SD43 might wear a little large on you.

No the 15400 probably wears slightly bigger, esp the white dial.

[zjd168]

people here never say redundant but always say both.

On the other hand the SD43 is indeed not redundant in your collection

[samson66]

Originally Posted by AK797

No the 15400 probably wears slightly bigger, esp the white dial.

Yeah but check out the Hulk shot. Look where the lugs fall on his wrist. Looks like the Sub is the perfect size. SD43 may be pushing it.

[antbkny]

Get one!