DD40 YG vs Daytona Oysterflex YG...(yeah another one of these)

[NLYogi]

Originally Posted by GoingPlaces

DD40 is the way to go, it's the flagship of Rolex. Especially in YG. Not a grandpa watch at all, worn by world leader for decades. Plus, the OF Daytona is too expensive, I'd all gold Daytona first.

I understand what you say but I would not get a DD because Obama or Idi Amin has one. Also not because it is a flagship model of Rolex. Somehow that is not the right emotional connection to have with a watch. Not deep enough.

Same for the Speedmaster. I don’t care if it was on the moon (ok, it is famous because it was. And without the moon trip we probably would never hear about it). For me it is nice to know it was on the moon, but it is such a great watch to see, wear and own. Same for the DD. It is pure emotion. Funny to try to describe this, guess I am a WIS somehow!

[GoingPlaces]

Originally Posted by NLYogi

I understand what you say but I would not get a DD because Obama or Idi Amin has one. Also not because it is a flagship model of Rolex. Somehow that is not the right emotional connection to have with a watch. Not deep enough.

Same for the Speedmaster. I don’t care if it was on the moon (ok, it is famous because it was. And without the moon trip we probably would never hear about it). For me it is nice to know it was on the moon, but it is such a great watch to see, wear and own. Same for the DD. It is pure emotion. Funny to try to describe this, guess I am a WIS somehow!

Definitely a WIS! A bit more romantic on the subject than I as well.

[Tampashooter]

If I want a rubber strap watch, I’ll wear my Panerai.

[Bxtek]

I love the DD but I also love that Daytona too! I can see how you would be torn in your decision between the two.

The DD is the classic flagship Rolex imo. It's the model that is recognized as a Rolex from 20 feet away, even by non-watch enthusiasts. It's dressy, classy, flashy and elegant all at the same time. Plus the features it has of the Day and Date is always handy. I've always loved the look of the hidden clasp. You can never really go wrong with this one imo.

The Daytona is obviously a much more modern style watch with the ceramic bezel, Oysterflex rubber strap, newer style of clasp, and of course the chrono function is the main feature here. I feel that it also can be dressy and flashy but also has that sporty look to it. Any watch enthusiast will know what this is and will most likely draw a conversation. To non-watch enthusiasts, you could be wearing an Invicta, a Bulova or similar and get the same respect. I guess what I'm saying is that there are a lot of lower end watches that roughly copy this same style.

I personally would probably go for the Daytona as I love the modern look/features, the chrono function, and how it can be used for casual wear as well as formal occasions. I think I know how you would feel though as the DD is also pretty striking and will always wonder if you made the right decision! I do prefer peterpl's dials tho, and I think the brown and green against the gold looks fantastic!

[Pacheco]

This one gives me plenty of life!! And I traded my WG Daytona for it because I needed a date and never used the chronograph.

[TimeToWatch]

Originally Posted by 3581512

I know, I know, another one of these "help me decide" posts, and ultimately I have to decide for myself.
But where else can I turn

The consensus seems to be the oysterflex Daytona is overpriced, at that msrp I should go for a full PM watch, since I don't have one already.
But taking cost out of the equation, I'm viewing this as an emotional vs usefulness debate.

The questions I've been asking myself are basically:
Since cost is similar, wouldn't it make sense to get the watch that would be used more?
How much weight should the emotional appeal of the DD affect the decision?


The Daytona would have much greater utility, it would easily be my daily watch and I could wear it without worry.
compared to the DD
-less flashy
-less worry about bezel or bracelet scuffs,
-still enough bling to keep me satisfied

In terms of usefulness, it definitely beats the daydate, but the downside is, it's not a day date.
Maybe Rolex marketing has really gotten me, but even with the Daytona I would likely still want a Day Date, even if that means the DD would stay home on many more occasions.
What do you think?

Sounds to me like you’re already sold on the Daytona, but just can’t wrap your head around the price. As you alluded to, I think you should remove cost from the equation and get the watch which speaks to you most. If you buy the watch you truly love, you won’t have to worry about flipping it in a couple years. And in terms of durability, as you’ve explained, the Daytona wins in a landslide.

This is the one I bought

[watchwatcher]

I think you're right...if you get the Daytona you'll still want the DD. And probably vice versa.

So it really doesn't matter which one you get first. Maybe the Daytona, since you see that as more of an everyday watch? Good luck,

[RoyalOac]

Daytonas belong on bracelets so by default the DD40 for me.

[Bxtek]

Originally Posted by Pacheco

This one gives me plenty of life!! And I traded my WG Daytona for it because I needed a date and never used the chronograph.

Originally Posted by TimeToWatch

Sounds to me like you’re already sold on the Daytona, but just can’t wrap your head around the price. As you alluded to, I think you should remove cost from the equation and get the watch which speaks to you most. If you buy the watch you truly love, you won’t have to worry about flipping it in a couple years. And in terms of durability, as you’ve explained, the Daytona wins in a landslide.

This is the one I bought

Alright guys......I made my "fantasy" choice of which watch I would pick, but with posts like these, I'm already second guessing myself! I have a feeling we aren't helping the OP too much at this point. Lol!

Love the dial on your DD Pacheco! Do you have a close up pic of the dial?

Your WG Daytona looks fantastic TimeToWatch! Now you're giving me a 3rd option to think about. Thankfully none of these are in my budget right now anyway. :)

[Devildog]

Originally Posted by Etschell

but would you shell out your cold hard cash for it over a full gold daytona on bracelet not strap?

I did. And I’d do it again

[watchmework]

Yg dd40

[BobDyl]

OysterFlex has a lot of fans on the forum. Personally, I don't like it, it just looks wrong and retrofitted to me, especially with the strange partial end links. Strongly believe the Daytona belongs on a bracelet. Speaking of bracelets, the DD President bracelet is one of the best of all time....

[doboy007]

DD screams old person. Love YG OF.

[rexG]

DD40 is an old mans watch?? Hardly. Its just in a different category.

[mj1214]

Originally Posted by GoingPlaces

DD40 is the way to go, it's the flagship of Rolex. Especially in YG. Not a grandpa watch at all, worn by world leader for decades. Plus, the OF Daytona is too expensive, I'd all gold Daytona first.

Agreed

[mj1214]

Originally Posted by rexg

dd40 is an old mans watch?? Hardly. Its just in a different category.

+1

[Investr]

I too considered these two. I felt the DD was just too dressy and a buddy of mine wears his all the time and I dont like it at all with casual clothes (AT ALL). The second we finish golf, he pops it on and i just feel it looks out of place with casual attire. Now the Daytona on OF- I bought the YG a month ago bc it has a sportier feel and look and the OF cuts the flash of an all gold piece. And the gold still gives it the right amount of bling. Love mine!!

[3581512]

Thanks for the replies everyone, happy to get others opinions on these two, gives me more to think about.

Originally Posted by watchwatcher

I think you're right...if you get the Daytona you'll still want the DD. And probably vice versa.

I think you're right about that.

Originally Posted by TimeToWatch

..

This is the one I bought
...

Great shot, looks amazing

Originally Posted by Pacheco

This one gives me plenty of life!! And I traded my WG Daytona for it because I needed a date and never used the chronograph.

Love the black dial on YG, I probably wouldn't use the chronograph much either

[Simon_e]

Originally Posted by Robbyman

DD looks like a grandad watch. Daytona looks like the wearer has some life left in them.

Which are you?

This suns it up perfectly.

A DD is a beautiful watch but the image is associated with old men. I will probably buy one when I am in my 60's. Until then the Daytona would be my choice.

[Pkim024]

Originally Posted by peterpl

LOL - dont think so. DD is a boss watch worn by ppl who are shot callers.

This... end of story.

[huncho]

Originally Posted by Simon_e

This suns it up perfectly.

A DD is a beautiful watch but the image is associated with old men. I will probably buy one when I am in my 60's. Until then the Daytona would be my choice.

not really sure how you can say this when the day date is one of the first watches most young athletes and celebs buy when they get money

[3581512]

I don't think the DD, especially in the 40mm size, is an old man watch at all

[T01]

As much as I love the OF Daytona, I’d go DD40. I see the OF as a piece to add after a full PM bracelet piece is already in the collection, especially considering the small price different in the grey market.

[bruinmd]

Originally Posted by Devildog

It’s all a matter of personal preference of course but the best looking watch in that picture by some margin is the YG Daytona on Oysterflex

Agreed

[MariettaMike]

Good choice whatever you choose.