Is the BLNR really just a poor substitute for a Pepsi or Coke?

[Baco Noir]

I think it’s the logical successor. The blue black makes the most sense for day and night sky colors. Red/blue and black/red don’t have a logical tie to day vs night.

[amh]

Not realistic given the hue of the 'red' in the BLRO. Doesn't look very red IMO.

Therefore, BLNR >> [New Pepsi || New Coke]

[tomchicago]

CokeC would Crash BLNR prices. "C" is for "Crash"

[mangoseed]

Originally Posted by Baco Noir

I think it’s the logical successor. The blue black makes the most sense for day and night sky colors. Red/blue and black/red don’t have a logical tie to day vs night.

Tying it to day and night doesn't make much sense anyway, rarely are there ever exactly 12 daylight hours in a day. The good thing about the Pepsi was contrast, not that the colors were a logical tie.

[101031-28]

I come from a time when GMT was primarily associated with blue/red color scheme. I will always be partial to this color combo. That being said, I find the BLNR to be 'innovative' with its blue/black configuration, and a joy to wear! Definitely not a poor substitute.

[JR16]

Originally Posted by kwingy

I wouldn't call it a poor substitute - it certainly has its admirers especially with the younger Rolex wearers as well. But I do think it lacks a certain nostalgic charm of the 16710 coke and Pepsi’s. Those watches have iconic status and I don't think the BLNR is quite there yet although it could be in a few years. I also think the BLNR is just a completely different watch DNA wise to its 5-digit counterpart. It probably explains why I have had 3 BLNR's and let them all go each time without any regret.

Agree but you can say this about any 5 digit vs 6 digit- I have a coke and a BLNR and love them equally . Different watches from different eras


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk Pro

[Krash]

I like the Black and Blue combination better than Coke or Pepsi. I like the Pepsi and Coke a lot, but I just like the Batman the best.

[kwingy]

Originally Posted by Duende01

You can try to convince yourself about your statement, however, any time one gets something more than once, there is a certain level of regret and thus the reason why it is re-aquired. Being that you have had three BLNRs, this strongly proves that you have regretted your decision at least twice, whether you want to admit it or not.

Well not really - a lot depends on the situations on why they acquired and let them go.

1st time it was because it was new and exciting but I didn't bond with it.
2nd time I managed to get it for list when prices were slowly rising so figured it was more a good opportunity to repurchase it but let it go for a Zenith Daytona.
3rd time was because I again managed to get it for a good price and then sold on for a small gain but mainly for finance reasons.

So for a serial flipper like me, it's not exactly hard to get behind the statement that I let them all go each time without any regret and you writing your opinion in bold is hardily going to make me doubt myself lol. And there have been threads on this forum regarding the fact that the BLNR is one of the most flipped watches.

[superstarmar]

In my personal and humble opinion since I’ve had one ...
Sorry I let it go ...

The BLNR takes a back seat to no watch !!!
It wasn’t meant to take the place of the
Pepsi or Coke , though quite a few might ...
It stands on its own and well you can clearly
see the demand is not going down soooo...

No !!!!

[Duende01]

Originally Posted by kwingy

Well not really - a lot depends on the situations on why they acquired and let them go.

1st time it was because it was new and exciting but I didn't bond with it.
2nd time I managed to get it for list when prices were slowly rising so figured it was more a good opportunity to repurchase it but let it go for a Zenith Daytona.
3rd time was because I again managed to get it for a good price and then sold on for a small gain but mainly for finance reasons.

So for a serial flipper like me, it's not exactly hard to get behind the statement that I let them all go each time without any regret and you writing your opinion in bold is hardily going to make me doubt myself lol. And there have been threads on this forum regarding the fact that the BLNR is one of the most flipped watches.

I wrote, "you can try to convince yourself"; No need to try to convince me. BTW, the bold is the way I write all my replies, so not trying to get you to doubt yourself. In that case, refer back to the beginning of my statement, lol.

[bobernet]

BLNR exists only because ceramic red was hard to do.

[denmanproject]

Nah, I'd keep my BLNR over a SS Coke or Pepsi any day

[Baco Noir]

Originally Posted by mangoseed

Tying it to day and night doesn't make much sense anyway, rarely are there ever exactly 12 daylight hours in a day. The good thing about the Pepsi was contrast, not that the colors were a logical tie.

You are correct about the inaccuracy of the 12/12 bezel coloration. That said, the split color is intended to allow easy distinction between day (6 am to 6 pm) and night time hours as you travel around the globe.

[kwingy]

Originally Posted by Duende01

I wrote, "you can try to convince yourself"; No need to try to convince me. BTW, the bold is the way I write all my replies, so not trying to get you to doubt yourself. In that case, refer back to the beginning of my statement, lol.

Well again if you write baseless statements like Being that you have had three BLNRs, this strongly proves that you have regretted your decision
as if to say you know me personally when we are just on a internet forum then I will of course respond appropriately. But then you are probably just on a windup.

We could go on all day really but your original comment aimed at me took this thread off course when people just want to discuss BLNR versus Pepsi and Coke so I will leave it at that and let it get back on topic.

[bjw]

Originally Posted by JR16

If a Pepsi or coke SS gmt is released (big IF), I think Rolex will retire the BLNR and keep supply the same .


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk Pro

This makes a lot of sense.

[doboy007]

Hell no! If BLRO came in SS I would still choose BLNR.

[Boaters]

Originally Posted by GolfPunk

My apologies I read that way too quick ... sorry. I’ll dekete my comment

No worries have a great day!

[10klakes]

Originally Posted by bobernet

BLNR exists only because ceramic red was hard to do.

I still think Rolex hasn't quite figured out the red ceramic or at least to my personal liking. I think the BLRO looks faded from day 1, both in pictures and in person.

Did the blue/black come to be, because Rolex couldn't figure out the red? Maybe. Poor substitute? Nah, not even close-

[Z3ke]

I find your question very odd. The blnr I thought was something new for rolex and the first of its kind. The black and blue complement each other nicely and is different from the coke bezel. Whether you like coke or pepsi is a matter of opinion. I think many appreciate the coke because of the history but I think the blnr will stay so long as demand for it stays. I also think even if a new iteration of the coke bezel comes out, the blnr will stay; i mean the thing sells above retail in the grey market and there are hardcore fans.

[Mrcoach32]

I don’t understand your question. Your question is so broad. Which Pepsi model are you comparing? Are you talking about the color scheme, the movement, the bracelet, or entire piece? Is it new vs the “they just don’t make ‘em like they used to” complaint? I could understand a broad question if the BLNR was a poor quality piece, but mechanically speaking it’s a more efficient upgrade and a scratch resistant bezel that doesn’t fade. If Rolex came out with a Pepsi or Coke model tomorrow, I’m betting dollars to donuts it’s the exact same piece as the BLNR but different color scheme. It’s not like the BLNR is trying to be something it’s not. It’s a GMT tool piece that does exactly what the other two do.

[jrs146]

Right. Just like the discontinued Kermit took a hit when the Hulk was introduced.

Oh, and the SD4K... prices of those are in the shitters once the SD43 came out.

I pity those who bought a SS Daytona just before the DaytonaC came out. Man did they lose their hats


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[WatchinMD]

BLNR is a winner. Great color combo. Ceramic insert is great

[AK797]

Originally Posted by 10klakes

I still think Rolex hasn't quite figured out the red ceramic or at least to my personal liking. I think the BLRO looks faded from day 1, both in pictures and in person.

Did the blue/black come to be, because Rolex couldn't figure out the red? Maybe. Poor substitute? Nah, not even close-

I'm sure they now have a nice crisp red or won't release one until they do. Maybe at the BLNR's time of release they were not happy with it, or maybe they just wanted to release a brand new watch. BLRO has no bearing on a RONR, different process.

[WJGESQ]

Originally Posted by mangoseed

If the Pepsi or Coke were reintroduced in SS then BLNR prices would most likely drop lower than the all black bezel.

Like a rock.


The world awaits the SS Coke.


Will be the hottest issue in years.


It just needs made.


Then, Batman will be a relic.

[superdog]

Originally Posted by WJGESQ

Like a rock.


The world awaits the SS Coke.


Will be the hottest issue in years.


It just needs made.


Then, Batman will be a relic.

I’d be all over a SS Coke GMT.

But it would have zero effect on the BLNR, which has been a hot watch since the day it came out.

[Jimbogigolo]

Blnr can definitely hold its own. Watch, once it’s discontinued it will command a high premium.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk Pro

[Pmt2]

Originally Posted by Jimbogigolo

Blnr can definitely hold its own. Watch, once it’s discontinued it will command a high premium.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk Pro

It already does.

[joejoe1225]

No


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[watchwatcher]

Originally Posted by watchwatcher

Surely if we've learned anything about the Rolex market, it's that if something "new" comes along, the "old" prices and demand go through the roof.

Originally Posted by jrs146

Right. Just like the discontinued Kermit took a hit when the Hulk was introduced.

Oh, and the SD4K... prices of those are in the shitters once the SD43 came out.

I pity those who bought a SS Daytona just before the DaytonaC came out. Man did they lose their hats

Exactly.

[Jcy90]

No