Is the BLNR really just a poor substitute for a Pepsi or Coke?

[mangoseed]

If the Pepsi or Coke were reintroduced in SS then BLNR prices would most likely drop lower than the all black bezel.

[Therolexlogin]

What makes you think this? I’d take the BLNR over the Pepsi or the Coke any day. IMO it’s more versatile than the other two.

[Andad]

Originally Posted by Therolexlogin

What makes you think this? I’d take the BLNR over the Pepsi or the Coke any day. IMO it’s more versatile than the other two.

Not sure what you mean Andy?

Wouldn't they just look like a BLNR with a different bezel?

[Onikage]

Depends on how much you like blue and black? I imagine it's all you're going to get in SS to be honest. Perhaps another entirely different combo but forget about old Coke or mighty Pepsi - The Rich Man's GMT.

[Quicksilver]

I have often wondered this myself. Its fair to say that the BLNR would take a hit if Rolex introduced SS Pepsi and/or Coke models. But I would not go so far as to say its a "poor substitute". The BLNR is a modern and beautiful take on the classic GMT bi-colour bezel and it will always be in demand and will always have its admirers.

[Mick8moses]

I love the BLNR color scheme as much as Coke and Pepsi, it's the band that keeps me at bay don't like PCLs. Now if it came on a jubilee...

Sent from my Nexus 6 using Tapatalk

[CRM114]

The BLNR is a great variation on the bi-color theme of the GMT. Looked at another way, it's a half-Blueberry.

[lord91]

No it's not, it' better from a tool watch pov: the blue for the day hours, black for night. Red is associated with temperatures, so not really its place on a GMT. Based on colour scheme alone, that depends on anyone's taste.

[Quailhunter]

When I bought my BLNR, the AD had a full selection of bi-colored, all black, all steel, and blue/black bezel watches.

The blue/black bezeled watch captured my heart. Cost had zero to do with the decision. I know a lot more about Rolex thanks to this forum and I’d still make the same decision.

My tastes lean toward conservative. YG DayDate, stainless DateJust, and. Calatrava along with the BLNR complete my small collection.

[Zakalwe]

Originally Posted by mangoseed

If the Pepsi or Coke were reintroduced in SS then BLNR prices would most likely drop lower than the all black bezel.

The bit in bold doesn't really make sense to me.

I'm sure most people would agree that the BLNR is more in demand than the LN. New variants of the GMT-II would not alter that equation. The BLNR would almost certainly take a hit in the advent of a SS Pepsi or Coke, but so would the LN. So whilst secondary BLNR prices might drop since you'd expect demand might reduce, exactly the same would happen to the LN.

No?

[Flier]

I dont understand how a watch can be a replacement for a can of soda

[lhawli]

No way! Might for a short bit, but then I would assume they would also discontinue the BLNR, which means it will be gaining value over time. Plus think about it, the color variation of the black and blue makes more sense than red/black or red/blue.

Black for night and blue for day. Plus it’s much more versatile than a Pepsi or Coke.

Human nature is to always go after what we don’t have. The thrill of the chase will always be more than the joy of owning.

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk Pro

[jaydav2306]

Originally Posted by Zakalwe

The bit in bold doesn't really make sense to me.

I'm sure most people would agree that the BLNR is more in demand than the LN. New variants of the GMT-II would not alter that equation. The BLNR would almost certainly take a hit in the advent of a SS Pepsi or Coke, but so would the LN. So whilst secondary BLNR prices might drop since you'd expect demand might reduce, exactly the same would happen to the LN.

No?

If anything this would push the BLNR value UP because it would be a candidate you would think for retirement.

Sure you can say this is about color preference but like someone has pointed out it's more about the blue of day and black of night so fits much better with the GMT in my opinion.

It's a future classic for sure

[yannis]

Well, BLNR is a more refined watch than the 5 digit reference (bracelet, ceramics, overall look and feel). I see it as an upgrade not as a substitute let alone a poor one. Of course 16710s are great watches, i am a fan and my first Rolex was a 16710.

Also i do not see how the price of BLNR could drop to a price lower than LN. How did you come up to this conclusion? Is there any reasoning behind it? Can you elaborate?

[Blingtone]

The original GMT was quickly adopted by Pan-Am pilots in the '50s and I'm guessing in those cramped and dim cockpit areas a Red/Blue bezel was more legible than a blue/black combo. ROLEX would undoubtedly have tested all the options back then.
I bought my GMT in '83 and I don't recall either a coke or black bezel choice then [I would not have chosen them anyway!] - I don't think these were introduced until the GMT II in the late 80s/ early 90s, which again was way, way before the BLNRs were introduced to a different sort of buyer/target audience.

[Zakalwe]

Originally Posted by jaydav2306

If anything this would push the BLNR value UP because it would be a candidate you would think for retirement.

Sure you can say this is about color preference but like someone has pointed out it's more about the blue of day and black of night so fits much better with the GMT in my opinion.

It's a future classic for sure

Yeah good point.

[epc2]

It's all about what you like there's no better than other, I love the pepsi bezel of the 16710 but the better clasp and bracelet of the 6 digits is a plus IMO , My problem with modern GMT's is the busy bezel with the big numbers but anyways I might still get one.

[brandrea]

Originally Posted by Quicksilver

I have often wondered this myself. Its fair to say that the BLNR would take a hit if Rolex introduced SS Pepsi and/or Coke models. But I would not go so far as to say its a "poor substitute". The BLNR is a modern and beautiful take on the classic GMT bi-colour bezel and it will always be in demand and will always have its admirers.

Spot on

[1William]

The BLNR is a beautiful watch and has been trading on a bubble since introduction. The prices have remained strong due to a lack of availability and discounting. Rolex will not introduce a SS Pepsi as the WG Pepsi has the market. If a SS coke bezel is introduced the BLNR will not face much of a reduction as you will not be able to get one for a long period of time. When availability exceeds demand then the BLNR will be adjusted downward in price. Simple in looking at Rolex and the restricted releases of models to AD's. If Rolex releases more volume you may see a different outcome.

[mountainjogger]

No.

[beshannon]

I prefer my BLNR so no

[Rokoru]

I think more sooner than later their will be a new bezel option when they start to introduce the new 32.. movements into the GMT´S.. Why not a Green Black bezel?

[airchitect]

I prefer the BLNR to the Coke and would never buy a mixed-berry Pepsi unless they actually got the colors right..

[GradyPhilpott]

Rolex makes a metal/ceramic GMTIIc to fit a broad range of tastes and budgets.

I honestly don't see how one can be a poor substitute for another, unless the buyer closes his eyes and just chooses one without regard to personal taste.

The BLNR is a beautiful bezel--far more beautiful than any one photo can capture.

If that doesn't tickle your fancy, then theirs the LN.

If that doesn't do it for you, then PM is the only other choice.

There is as yet no Coke bezel in six-digits, so if that's what tugging at your heartstrings, you're just going to have to wait.

[Spartacus]

The BLNR was the first mixed color ceramic bezel. I thought the issue with the BLRO was that it was so hard/$ to create the bezels, so it is only applied to WG examples.

The blue color has multiple references in the GMT lineage. The GMT line is ripe for a refresh, I wonder if a "Blueberry" platinum or white gold model is released this year.

[superdog]

The way you word your question, leads one to believe that there is a consensus that the BLNR is a substitute of some kind. When it is not.

It is actually one of the most popular watches on the planet today. Whatever that is worth to you, or anyone else. But either way, it is a fact.

Doesn't appear that any Rolex watch is a substitute of one thing or another.

[Nairn1980]

Originally Posted by mangoseed

If the Pepsi or Coke were reintroduced in SS then BLNR prices would most likely drop lower than the all black bezel.

I’d happily keep my BLNR and 16710 Pepsi.
Best of both worlds.

Ps, if you’re waiting for a Steel Pepsi, you’ll be waiting a long time.

[Juantxo]

The blnr is not as flashy as the others with red.

[Devildog]

Originally Posted by jaydav2306

If anything this would push the BLNR value UP because it would be a candidate you would think for retirement.

Sure you can say this is about color preference but like someone has pointed out it's more about the blue of day and black of night so fits much better with the GMT in my opinion.

It's a future classic for sure

I'm not sure it would. Rolex invested heavily in the two colour ceramic bezel process. That amount of R&D cost takes a long time to be recovered.

[AK797]

If a CokeC is released I think BLNR prices would merely stabilise, greys would withstand early selling pressure from those wanting to instantly switch, this isn't their first rodeo, and then as the new release slowly drips into the market, frustrated demand will turn back on the BLNR and continue to keep prices stable. If it is discoed, prices will rise, but that's very unlikely.