Trade my 10 year old 5167 for a new 5164?

[gregvisser]

Hi all,

Been offered a trade for my 10 year old 5167 for a new 5164. I really like the TT complication.

Do it or pass?

Greg

[norcalgt3]

a 5167r or a 5167a?

if 5167a, the other person is getting hosed

[Coolcamden]

How is that equitable?

[subtona]

the price differential in the trade may be relevant for others to offer an opinion.

For me I would just keep the 67. The slimness of the 67 is non negotiable feature of the aquanaut imho.

[brandrea]

Are you saying that it is a straight up trade?

If so, I’d do that in a heartbeat

[srvrf]

I like the dial and functionality of the 5164 compared to the 5167. So if I had the chance to trade my 5167R towards a 5164 or 5164R I'd definitely consider it.

[7sins]

Definitely plus the added gmt benefit of the 5164, prefer the dial and case layout to the 5164 as well. Home run IMO.

[fsprow]

Have both. Wear the 5164A much more.

[V25V]

Cannot see why someone would do that trade straight up. An R, maybe. I have wanted an R for a long time and have a 5164A, no way I would even do that trade. If you are being offered a straight up trade 5167A for 5164A, YES DO IT. No brainer.

[Humble michael]

So are we talking about some cash and the 5164 or is the 64 an R ??

[gregvisser]

My bad - I should have said it is not an equitable trade and needs US$22k cash to make work.

I was more interested in whether I am chasing my own tail in doing it, but now realise it is hard to separate value from the discussion.

Greg

[Halothane]

I would do it. 5164 is next level. Best Aquanaut imo

[agsstructures]

I would do it!

[patlex]

NIKE - just do it ;-)

[enjoythemusic]

Originally Posted by gregvisser

... but now realise it is hard to separate value from the discussion.

When was your 5167 serviced?

[gregvisser]

Originally Posted by enjoythemusic

When was your 5167 serviced?

Never serviced, still runs perfectly.

[srvrf]

If the 5164A is fairly new, I think that's a fair trade and I'd do it. The difference in MSRP now is about $17k USD and the $5k difference should cover the fact that it is quite a bit older and will need service in the near future.

[IamJacky]

Originally Posted by gregvisser

My bad - I should have said it is not an equitable trade and needs US$22k cash to make work.

I was more interested in whether I am chasing my own tail in doing it, but now realise it is hard to separate value from the discussion.

Greg

So a 10 year old never serviced 5167A + $22k cash and get a brand new 2022 5164A, for me I would definitely do this trade.

[seadubs]

Originally Posted by IamJacky

So a 10 year old never serviced 5167A + $22k cash and get a brand new 2022 5164A, for me I would definitely do this trade.

agree

[gregvisser]

Thanks guys. This gives me a bit of confidence to do the deal. I might see if I can move the cash contribution a little closer to the market - the $5k premium seems a bit high.

[GB-man]

Both great but I much prefer the 5164 so yeah

[Humble michael]

Yep I have a 64R I dearly love. Usually is my favorite to travel with. I would offer 17-18500 max difference. That would be a great trade imo . Wish you the best , michael in San Antonio Tx.:—))