Need help for a potential 5513 purchase

[cmoray]

Hi,
There is a 5513 for sale locally.  I tried to check the details using the information from 5513 website but I want to make sure if I don't miss anything.  I would really appreciate it if you can help.  Thanks alot.

[swish77]

Hard to tell for sure because there's so much glare on the photos. I can tell you that the insert pearl is way too big and shouldn't have a metal surround. What is the beginning of the serial number?

I'd suggest getting clearer photos in natural light.

What are your concerns exactly?

[Dan S]

Yeah, I think the insert is for a 5-digit reference. Something I learned recently myself. The dial and hands look nice in those photos. Serial and inside-caseback photos?

[cmoray]

From the serial, I can say that it is made in 1966. The seller states that it is all original. Prices vary alot on a vintae Rolex depending on the condition of the watch so I don't want to make a mistake.

[cmoray]

Originally Posted by Dan S

Yeah, I think the insert is for a 5-digit reference. Something I learned recently myself. The dial and hands look nice in those photos. Serial and inside-caseback photos?

I will ask for for it tomorrow.

[swish77]

Originally Posted by cmoray

From the serial, I can say that it is made in 1966. The seller states that it is all original. Prices vary alot on a vintae Rolex depending on the condition of the watch so I don't want to make a mistake.

Well, it's not all original, as established above, so that's a red flag for starters.

[cmoray]

Originally Posted by swish77

Well, it's not all original, as established above, so that's a red flag for starters.

I agree with you. The seller may not know about it but at least he should not mislead.

[GGGMT]

Not all original and obviously so; so seller is either misleading or doesn’t know what he’s talking about. I’d err on the side of cynicism.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[cmoray]

I think there is another possibility that a bigger pearl was mounted by making a bigger hole on the bezel.

[cmoray]

Ok here is the story. Seller is a watchsmith. He told me that bezel is original and he mounted the pearl but without making a bigger hole on the bezel.

[Dan S]

I don't know. Shouldn't a meters-first dial have a long-five insert?

[watchmaker]

The case middle has a lot of pitting on the gasket mating surface. That is not good and can mean the waterproofness cannot be guaranteed anymore.

[cmoray]

Thanks for all the info. I think I will pass this one.

[southtexas]

How much is he asking for it?


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[soicanbefree]

I really hate that pearl. If he is a watchmaker and didn't immediately discuss or disclose that when you first talked about the sale it is a bit of a problem.

The rest of the condition of that insert isn't great.

Case pitting isn't great.

It all depends on price of course and depends on your goals / what you want.

[cmoray]

Originally Posted by southtexas

How much is he asking for it?


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

12k but I did not bargain for it.

[cmoray]

Originally Posted by soicanbefree

I really hate that pearl. If he is a watchmaker and didn't immediately discuss or disclose that when you first talked about the sale it is a bit of a problem.

The rest of the condition of that insert isn't great.

Case pitting isn't great.

It all depends on price of course and depends on your goals / what you want.

This is the very reason that gave me a sour taste.

[southtexas]

I wouldn’t let a fake pearl bother me too much. A lot of old school watchmakers didn’t/don’t care about such details. They replaced an item with something that fit if they didn’t have access to an original. Who would’ve thought an original pearl mattered to anyone?


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[charlitos]

I think right insert, but fake pearl

[kwcsports]

I like it. Fake pearl is easily fixed. I once saw a 5513 with a diamond instead of pearl haha.

[cmoray]

What do you think about the price given the situation? Too steep I guess.

[theflywrist]

Fake pearl is correct, but also damaged the insert to "drill" it in. That to me effects the value.
I personally believe that in this market you can find significantly better for not MUCH higher.
It's a nice watch, but I'd continue my hunt for a stronger example, that's just me.