Which Rolex should I keep??

[Dynamin]

So I own 2 datejust. I'm gonna sell or trade in 1 of those for a President datejust.

I just cant make up my mind which datejust I want to part with. Its like trying to pick between 2 beautiful girlfriends.

So in your opinion which watch is the most beautiful keeper, and which one should I sell??

[rpdur]

Keep the one that contrasts most from the Day-Date you intend to purchase.

[goldboy]

I think we have different taste in girlfriends.

Keep the one that speaks to you, my friend.

[cdmorenot]

I'd keep the blue dial!

[EmpireCity]

Does one hold more sentimental value than the other?

[skipstar]

I would trade both of them unless either one has sentimental value

[IsItFridayYet]

Originally Posted by skipstar

I would trade both of them unless either one has sentimental value

Agreed

[tifosi]

Trade 'em both, for sure!

[Pauln]

I would sell both.

[APhound]

What’s a president datejust?
Neither of those are my style- I would start over with all due respect.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[huba01]

sell both

[jefrkw]

if this happen to me I sell both and trade tosport watch like ss daytona, submariner, GMT II

[Chadridv]

Originally Posted by rpdur

Keep the one that contrasts most from the Day-Date you intend to purchase.

good advice.

I know nothing about those DJs. Value, rarity, difficulty to get, etc. Have to admit too, neither is my cup of tea, so I think the advice above is good. Get the one that best compliments your new day-date.

[MickCollins1916]

Neither of those DJs are in my personal wheelhouse, but if one sings to you, keep it.

If trading both towards a full gold DJ is what you’re considering, I’d be all for it.

Or, if you’re seeking a Day-Date on president bracelet, I’d recommend doing that. The DD is a fantastic watch and there are many iterations to choose from. The president bracelet is very comfortable on the wrist.

[ThomasCrown]

Sell the one that has the least attachment, otherwise sell both imo.

[brandrea]

Originally Posted by rpdur

Keep the one that contrasts most from the Day-Date you intend to purchase.

Originally Posted by Chadridv

good advice.

I know nothing about those DJs. Value, rarity, difficulty to get, etc. Have to admit too, neither is my cup of tea, so I think the advice above is good. Get the one that best compliments your new day-date.

I agree with these folks ^^^

[iamGhana]

sell / trade both honestly.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[mg18]

Offload both and start over.

[Podmornica]

Yeah, both are ugly .. I would sell them and buy something decent ..

[tifosi]

Originally Posted by Podmornica

Yeah, both are ugly .. I would sell them and buy something decent ..

Well that's.....direct.

[Turb0wned]

Get rid of both of them

[Chadridv]

Originally Posted by Podmornica

Yeah, both are ugly .. I would sell them and buy something decent ..

tell us how you really feel!

[MrMercedes]

Originally Posted by tifosi

Trade 'em both, for sure!

100% this!

[wgdaytona]

You asked, so I would sell both, too much bling. But, you should do what feels right for you.

[SS Oyster]

No such thing as president datejust


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[Dynamin]

Originally Posted by EmpireCity

Does one hold more sentimental value than the other?

Not really

[Dynamin]

Originally Posted by Pauln

I would sell both

Not an option. I want a Rolex backup when my President is in the shop

[Tridor]

Keep the blue dial.

[winst]

Sell both if you are getting the El Presidente!

[HERITAGE82]

If your going bold anyway the go all the way....Keep the Blue Dial.