Reconditioned 5512 value

[Yobber76]

I found a 1959 5512 in a Rolex dealer that has been serviced recently by Rolex
The watch has a new dial and the bracelet is not original
Watch is in great condition and runs to standards
They are asking 10 k while not collectible it is absolutely wearable
Is it worth the purchase?

Your thoughts are appreciated thanks

[southtexas]

Wow what a shame. Any pics?


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[Yobber76]

No not at this time the store is in a state I traveled to this week
It appears Rolex changed the bracelet with the oldest model they had available it looks pretty new they changed the dial because of lead in the old dial

[exador]

For $10k you can get an original 5513. Probably a better bet.

[1665fan]

Yea 10k non original dial is not soo good.

[E46seca]

I Think to get the best opinion on buy or not , pictures would make a world of difference.

Also what original parts may remain ? Was the insert changed out ?

At $10k it's not the best deal I've heard of and certainly a proper dial will cost more then the watch itself. Hope this helps in the decision process


Cheers

[05carbondrz]

Originally Posted by Yobber76

No not at this time the store is in a state I traveled to this week
It appears Rolex changed the bracelet with the oldest model they had available it looks pretty new they changed the dial because of lead in the old dial

Lead in the Dial? That’s a new One!

[Yobber76]

Thanks everyone for your comments.
When I saw this watch, I was amazed by it's condition, and asked the salesman at the store to send me the details of the work Rolex had done.
As I traveled home I tried to find pictures that would show me what a 5512 of that age should look like, including the bracelet and clasp. I was convinced the bracelet was not the original, especially the clasp, and the dial and hands seemed too pristine.
Not knowing to what lengths Rolex would go in a recondition, I started asking questions, and learned that the watch had been modified.
To be honest, I had had the urge to consider a 5 digit 14060 or even a 16610, so when I stumbled on this watch, I was at first excited, but then became cautious as the price seemed too good to be true for anything with original parts, regardless of what Rolex might do .
This was my first attempt at a vintage watch, and I thought my best advice would come from the people of this forum, with your vast knowledge of the history of Rolex watches.
Based on my findings and confirmed by your comments, I decided to pass on this watch.
I will continue to look at the 5 digit subs, and ask for your help in the future.

Thanks again

[tekno]

“Dear Sir,
We removed the lead, and the value from your watch.

Sincerely,
Rolex”


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk Pro