5146G for my first Patek Philippe?

[Jojoshop]

Really nice, elegant and timeless piece. The white dial is my favorite.

[Toffeeman]

Anyone has a view on choice between 5146G and say 5205R-010? I was offered 5205R in lieu for the 5235G being discontinued. But my heart says 5146G is the preferred piece, I feel 5146G being less formal and agile for different activities. Also the deployant clasp with the calatrava cross is too hard to resist.

Appreciate thoughts on this.

[G M Francis]

I had a 5205 originally, traded it and got a 5146. The 5205 IMO is a beautiful watch and looks best when worn with a suit or jacket. I didn’t feel it was a very versatile watch to wear when I dressed down. I think an AC or Perp C should be a daily wearer , I’ve got the 5146 now and I’m very happy with it. My only suggestion is the grey dial over the cream from the point of legibility.

[ShawnsteR]

Congrats Ts. I'm also looking to purchase the 5146 as a memento for my big day coming this Sep. Will be my first PP.

Had a hard time deciding between the 5146 or the A. Lange 1.
Now stressing over which metal to get it in, I love both RG and WG.

[sirish19]

I bought my 5146 about 4 years ago and still love it. Bought it on the secondary market and haven't really lost much money out of it. Don't plan to sell it either as it is my grail piece, my complicated piece, and the cornerstone of my holy trinity. It is the epitome of the Patek DNA.

I have while gold with white face and a grey strap. I is about time to replace the strap so thinking of going custom with two straps, one in a shade of brown and one in a shade of grey to mix things up a bit.


Congratulations on your purchase_

[RyanO]

Originally Posted by tyong

Finally, I've got it!

Gorgeous, congratulations! I also think this is an underrated, classic reference - enough so that I am pulling the trigger on a slate dial 5146g this week. Cannot wait!

How are you enjoying yours? Are you happy with it?

I am hoping to change the strap color from brown to grey.

Will post a pic once I get it.

[FJT]

Congrats. Looks amazing.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[turborolex]

It’s a nice reference, but the deal has to be out of this world. My friend was offered $20,000- 21,000 from multiple dealers for his almost near new, mint 5146G.

That’s around 50% off MSRP.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[JorgeCCW]

Originally Posted by turborolex

It’s a nice reference, but the deal has to be out of this world. My friend was offered $20,000- 21,000 from multiple dealers for his almost near new, mint 5146G.

That’s around 50% off MSRP.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Yup, sounds about right. If you buy at 27-28k and make peace with yourself that you are gonna lose 7k if you depart from it. Then you are good .




Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[RyanO]

Originally Posted by turborolex

It’s a nice reference, but the deal has to be out of this world. My friend was offered $20,000- 21,000 from multiple dealers for his almost near new, mint 5146G.

That’s around 50% off MSRP.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

I would imagine he could do a little better selling it himself here on TRF?

[RyanO]

As promised, a photo of mine that I recently added to the collection.



Just sourced the grey strap from an AD in Miami. Surprisingly, it wasn’t terribly easy to find.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[RyanO]

Originally Posted by JorgeCCW

Yup, sounds about right. If you buy at 27-28k and make peace with yourself that you are gonna lose 7k if you depart from it. Then you are good .




Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Jorge, you would definitely be the one to ask on this subject. Have you observed the market continuing to soften on these references? Or has it pretty much remained stable?

[JorgeCCW]

Originally Posted by RyanO

Jorge, you would definitely be the one to ask on this subject. Have you observed the market continuing to soften on these references? Or has it pretty much remained stable?

I haven’t followed closely but I suspect hasn’t changed significantly. But now that the sport watches has soften a little, 5146 might go down slightly, not significantly. But then again the market might go up again once the summer is over. Historically watch market in general softens a little on the summer


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[RyanO]

Originally Posted by JorgeCCW

I haven’t followed closely but I suspect hasn’t changed significantly. But now that the sport watches has soften a little, 5146 might go down slightly, not significantly. But then again the market might go up again once the summer is over. Historically watch market in general softens a little on the summer


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Appreciate your insights. Prices definitely seem to be softening for sports pieces, will be interesting to see if it’s just a summer slowdown...


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[Stingerstingray]

I'm glad to have found this post. I'm considering a 5146 as my first pp as well and have been doing a lot of research. Initially, I loved the contrast color in a 5146j 010 and later found a 5146g with the slate dial to be more versatile for both dressy and casual. Recently I started to find a 5146g with a cream or white dial very attractive. I imagine the latter model with the cream dial would look great with different colors of straps.

Sent from my LGMP260 using Tapatalk

[lej88]

Originally Posted by Stingerstingray

I'm glad to have found this post. I'm considering a 5146 as my first pp as well and have been doing a lot of research. Initially, I loved the contrast color in a 5146j 010 and later found a 5146g with the slate dial to be more versatile for both dressy and casual. Recently I started to find a 5146g with a cream or white dial very attractive. I imagine the latter model with the cream dial would look great with different colors of straps.

Sent from my LGMP260 using Tapatalk

For reference (not really good with taking pictures )

White gold 5146G


Yellow gold 5146J


Rose gold 5146R



Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[Liops]

Great watch

[jag32]

I have it’s predecessor the 5035J which I love. Also probably the best deal in Patek around at only $19k right now.

[BreguetRolex]

Originally Posted by JorgeCCW

The watch is the best bang for your buck on the Patek line up. Versatile, useful, descent lumen , patek DNA. You should be able to get a good discount for this watch. Even with discount , let’s say you get it for $30k (US) when selling be prepared to lose at least 6k, if not more.

If you don’t care about that then you are good.
Would I buy this watch even though I really like it ? No , Me personally I can’t buy it because even if I am lucky and keep it for 1 year , I can’t afford to lose 6k , that of course counting that I got it for 30k from an AD. Like I said, if these economic restraints don’t apply to you then do it

Best of luck


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

sure seems it is always how big a loss your going to take..? Surely not everyone is looking at it that way I would think... Same as 5524G with loss factor..

[BreguetRolex]

Originally Posted by tyong

Hi guys,

I'm making the final decision to buy a Patek Philippe this month. And this is going to be my first PP. I'm interested in the 5146G-001 model and it has one at my dealer in Bangkok.



Should I start with this model? Is this a good choice? I rarely see any posts about this model. Actually, I really like the face and the comfort. I don't think I can afford PP more than one (at least in next few years).

I'd like the watch that doesn't look too dressy, a bit casual but not a sport watch. Can wear it everyday. Doesn't concern much about price depreciation. Please help to provide me your advises, or should I go for other model? thank you very much

My recent watch collection is shows in the picture..
1. RL Submariner 116610LN
2. RL GMT Master II 116710BLNR
3. RL Explorer II 216570
4. PAM 510
5. GS SBGA127

Awesome watch and worth every penny..

[JorgeCCW]

Originally Posted by BreguetRolex

sure seems it is always how big a loss your going to take..? Surely not everyone is looking at it that way I would think... Same as 5524G with loss factor..

Of course not , everyone has different habits and different financials, but no matter what I think is smart to be educated with this kind of information before hand. Make it a factor on your decision when buying but never the only factor , otherwise the hobby becomes a transaction.

Cheers


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[RyanO]

Originally Posted by Stingerstingray

I'm glad to have found this post. I'm considering a 5146 as my first pp as well and have been doing a lot of research. Initially, I loved the contrast color in a 5146j 010 and later found a 5146g with the slate dial to be more versatile for both dressy and casual. Recently I started to find a 5146g with a cream or white dial very attractive. I imagine the latter model with the cream dial would look great with different colors of straps.

Sent from my LGMP260 using Tapatalk

I agree regarding the versatility of the slate dial. It is my favorite dial, but I also find the cream very classy and slightly dressier. IMO you can’t go wrong with either, and hope to see your incoming soon!


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[wisguy]

I was torn on the dial and between the 5146 and 5396, once on the wrist the choice was much easier

[ezinhk]

Congrats on your 1st PP! It’s gotten more expensive buying watches in BKK due to increase in THB.

[Stingerstingray]

Originally Posted by RyanO

I agree regarding the versatility of the slate dial. It is my favorite dial, but I also find the cream very classy and slightly dressier. IMO you can’t go wrong with either, and hope to see your incoming soon!


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Thanks, Ryan. I decided to go with the 5145g with the cream dial. Now I need some advice on who and where to order custom straps. I'll also post some photos once I have the watch. :-)

Sent from my LGMP260 using Tapatalk

[SomaSker]

@Stingerstingray: I've ordered a few straps from Camille Fournet in Paris--excellent quality and really cool customization's you can make:

https://www.camillefournet.com/en/wa...ed-watch-strap

[DGP]

Congrats on joining the “Patek Family “. My brother has same watch and I bought the 5146j. I think they are a lot of “bang for your bucks” compared to some other PP’s.
Enjoy wearing it.

[Claymie]

Love to hear anyone’s view on dial legibility. I like the slate because it seems a bit more sporty but is it harder to read than the white or cream? Seems so in pictures.

I recently sold a world timer for this reason. Getting old I suppose...

[Erson]

Start with the Nautilus or 5205R black dial

[MilesB]

Originally Posted by Claymie

Love to hear anyone’s view on dial legibility. I like the slate because it seems a bit more sporty but is it harder to read than the white or cream? Seems so in pictures.

I recently sold a world timer for this reason. Getting old I suppose...

In bright light it's harder to read, i.e. it'll take a few more seconds. In lower light the contrast oddly becomes very good.