Your Thoughts on the 5196

[simontre]

What do you guys think?
Too big for a classic Tux watch?

Possible alternatives?

Thanks

[mps354]

I like all versions of the 5196...especially in platinum. I think it would be fine with a tux

[subtona]

Originally Posted by mps354

I like all versions of the 5196...especially in platinum. I think it would be fine with a tux

Agree the 5196P is a favorite

[incontrol]

Originally Posted by mps354

I like all versions of the 5196...especially in platinum. I think it would be fine with a tux

The 5196p is stunning. I would wear it with formal and casual.

[SearChart]

Stunning piece, but the long lugs make it wear quite large on small wrists I suppose.

[subtona]

Originally Posted by SearChart

Stunning piece, but the long lugs make it wear quite large on small wrists I suppose.

Agree,
I tried it on along with the 5170, the long lugs of the 5196 and the generous dial size made it feel more like a 40mm watch than it's actual 37mm size.

[mps354]

Originally Posted by subtona

Agree,
I tried it on along with the 5170, the long lugs of the 5196 and the generous dial size made it feel more like a 40mm watch than it's actual 37mm size.

Completely agree

[cervantes]

Every time I put on the Platinum version thinking I'm going to love it, somethings missing.
Does wear larger than the number.

[simontre]

Thanks everybody

[RussW]

I like the 5196 very much, but be aware it has no display back.

[subtona]

Originally Posted by RussW

I like the 5196 very much, but be aware it has no display back.

Nothing to see with the old tiny workhorse of a movement.

[RussW]

Originally Posted by subtona

Nothing to see with the old tiny workhorse of a movement.

Haha, very true

[Par401]

I love my 5196J. I wear it a lot more than I thought I would when I bought it.











I actually like the solid back case, it gives it a heavier solid feel to the watch. I think one of the best features of the watch is the brushed side of the case. The most dress watches has polished and this was one of the big reasons I chose it.

[Slider817]

Good Choice, although basically every Patek Calatrava is a good simple dress watch option, just get whichever you love that is within your budget.

I prefer the automatic Patek Calatrava, having the display back is a must for me at watches at this price point and if you cannot see the movement why are you paying for the decoration.

[mps354]

Originally Posted by cervantes

Every time I put on the Platinum version thinking I'm going to love it, somethings missing.
Does wear larger than the number.

I think it would be better with a matte black strap instead of a shiny one

[locutus49]

Calatrava is entry level. I would shoot for the 5170. But it is your money so it is easy to spend.

[cervantes]

Originally Posted by mps354

I think it would be better with a matte black strap instead of a shiny one

I hear that. I find a few Pateks need some matte to really shine. Including the new 5170g Black.

[topcat30093]

Originally Posted by incontrol

The 5196p is stunning. I would wear it with formal and casual.

I agree

[subtona]

Originally Posted by Par401

I love my 5196J. I wear it a lot more than I thought I would when I bought it.


I actually like the solid back case, it gives it a heavier solid feel to the watch. I think one of the best features of the watch is the brushed side of the case. The most dress watches has polished and this was one of the big reasons I chose it.

That is a beauty and so classic.

[drhr]

Fell for the P the minute I laid eyes on it, it'll never leave . . .

[mps354]

Originally Posted by drhr

Fell for the P the minute I laid eyes on it, it'll never leave . . .

Love the second pic...really shows off the dial

[el1125]

Originally Posted by drhr

Fell for the P the minute I laid eyes on it, it'll never leave . . .

This is a very beautiful watch

[p_mcgee]

I had the 5196R for about 5 years before flipping it. Loved it but never wore it and couldn't justify tying up 16K in the safe.

The watch wears larger than 37mm but I don't think too large for a tux. As far as alternatives I'd look at the Lange Saxonia or 1815, the VC Patrimony Traditionelle, or maybe an entry level FP Journe.

[kneedeep]

The pictures do not do the P justice. Saw one and the dial is amazing. Loved it for a dress watch.

[topcat30093]

I would love to add the 5196P to my small collection.

It's a great looking piece and of course you have that diamond :)

[drhr]

Originally Posted by el1125

This is a very beautiful watch

Thx! Simple, subtle, sublime!!!

[PJ S]

Originally Posted by p_mcgee

I had the 5196R for about 5 years before flipping it. Loved it but never wore it and couldn't justify tying up 16K in the safe.

The watch wears larger than 37mm but I don't think too large for a tux. As far as alternatives I'd look at the Lange Saxonia or 1815, the VC Patrimony Traditionelle, or maybe an entry level FP Journe.

You missed one – H Moser & Cie.
Thicker than the 5196, but every bit as good, and then some.
Iirc, their production numbers are similar to FPJ – circa 1000 per annum.

[Abdullasaif]

Originally Posted by drhr

Fell for the P the minute I laid eyes on it, it'll never leave . . .

My favourite calatrava!!