Trying to Choose my First Patek

[rjohnston713]

Hi All,

I am looking to purchase my first Patek. We do have an AD here but nothing in the current catalog is super enticing to me outside of a 5712 which I won't hold my breath on so look at other options.

I am not a fan of vintage watches and want something automatic newer than 2000. I also like more subtle watches and have a smaller wrist (I daily a 36mm Explorer most days). I'd consider a new Calatrava if they had one in White Dial/Brown Strap

What would be the most bang for the buck as a first Patek among the following list? Any pros or cons on them? Are the prices I have next to them realistic for a full set of box and papers?

5146G White/Cream Dial - 35k for set?
3940G White Dial/Brown Strap - 60-70k for set?
5140G White Dial/Brown Strap - 40-50k for set?
5320G Cream Dial - 70k for set?


Any others references that you would consider? Would love to keep it below 50k which rules out the 5550P

[Horologista]

All those are great watches.
5035 might be worth considering as well.
It’s a mix of some of the elements of 5146 in that it’s an annual calendar and 3940 in that it’s an older and smaller reference.

[Bmats]

I’m a big fan of the 5146. And you can find newer ones before discontinuation in that general range with the 324 versus the 315 movement (not sure it matters much though).

It’s a great size at 39mm and almost wears smaller given the case shape and bezel.

[agsstructures]

3940G is a beautiful piece. I daily one and love the fact that no one knows what it is. Full set with original papers (not archive) will be on the higher end of your range. 5140G also a great piece and you should be able to find a full set within your range.

[ts3]

The 3940 would be my favorite among your options but I'd prefer P over G as Patek used plated WG well into the 2000s. In addition, I'd also look at the 5110 WT unless you require a date.

[rjohnston713]

Originally Posted by ts3

The 3940 would be my favorite among your options but I'd prefer P over G as Patek used plated WG well into the 2000s. In addition, I'd also look at the 5110 WTs unless you require a date.

Interesting I was unaware of the WG plating, thats great info. For the 3940P at that point are we at $100K+ for the set? If I got to the point of spending $100k would almost want to go the extra mile and just have it be the 5550P

[bp1000]

3940 or 5320G cream dial.