Poll: 5164 plus Daytona 116500 or 5712

[AK797]

Inspired by the other 5712 poll thread, thought I'd put this up for fun as this is really a tough choice for me.

[Fat_ninja]

5712 cause it’s my nautilus grail

[Rushne]

I absolutely love the 5712.
But in this case I’ll take the 5164 and Daytona

[ap1]

12 is tough to top. Maybe an 11 and Daytona does it

[Ichiran]

Originally Posted by ap1

12 is tough to top. Maybe an 11 and Daytona does it

For me, either a 11 or 5740 top the 12. For this poll, I chose 12.

[Vipes]

I like the 5164 and Daytona better. More versatile having these 2. I favor the 5711 over the 5712.

[AshAP]

I’d go for the Aquanaut and the Daytona but only the white face version - the premium on this watch is crazy, Watchfinder had one on at £23,950 and it’s sold in less than a week.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[Fat_ninja]

Originally Posted by AshAP

I’d go for the Aquanaut and the Daytona but only the white face version - the premium on this watch is crazy, Watchfinder had one on at £23,950 and it’s sold in less than a week.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

The white face is really hard to get. No one has yet to sell me one. It’s pretty upsetting

[Aquaman]

Why does every deviate from the actual question,

He's said 2 choices, not this that and the other

I say 5712

[rkot07]

5712 gets my vote


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[RHIII]

Assuming both at retail, it would be the 12 for me. Hands down my friend!!!


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[JR16]

If this was the entirety of my collection, I would say 5164 plus 500. If I had another Rolex in my collection, then 5712.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk Pro

[ts3]

5712, much easier than the other poll

[s.m.b.]

5164 plus Daytona 116500.

[Fat_ninja]

This is one of the few nautilus still climbing in a slightly softer environment...

I will bet this reference hits 150k by next Basel

Don’t blow your wad and sell too early for anyone thinking about selling. It’s easy to sell but harder to be greedy...

[RussW]

64 plus Daytona for me

[Sam Philip]

5712A at MSRP

[s.m.b.]

Originally Posted by Fat_ninja

This is one of the few nautilus still climbing in a slightly softer environment...

I will bet this reference hits 150k by next Basel

Don’t blow your wad and sell too early for anyone thinking about selling. It’s easy to sell but harder to be greedy...

With an established relationship, the 5712 is easier to get from an AD than an Aquanaut or a 5711. I was offered one this year and passed on account of it doing little for me. Unless it's discontinued, I don't see it hitting $150,000.

[AK797]

I think I'd choose the 5712 if I didn't have a Nautilus but as I do, I do own the other two.

[Fat_ninja]

Originally Posted by s.m.b.

With an established relationship, the 5712 is easier to get from an AD than an Aquanaut or a 5711. I was offered one this year and passed on account of it doing little for me. Unless it's discontinued, I don't see it hitting $150,000.

:). Soon my friend.


Then they can make the asymmetric dial for the aquanaut... then everyone can go ape chit crazy :)

[ap1]

Originally Posted by Fat_ninja

:). Soon my friend.


Then they can make the asymmetric dial for the aquanaut... then everyone can go ape chit crazy :)

Tell you wut ninja. I’ll give you a discount, 100k and you can have mine. For your daughter of course.
Then she can go to Princeton over Rutgers with that in her 529

102k if you want the 1.5 link

[GB-man]

I forbid you to sell the 5164 Neil

If anything sell the daytona. I also forbid paying market rate on a 5712.

[Fat_ninja]

Originally Posted by ap1

Tell you wut ninja. I’ll give you a discount, 100k and you can have mine. For your daughter of course.
Then she can go to Princeton over Rutgers with that in her 529

102k if you want the 1.5 link

Lol


You do realize she can get it at retail?

[ct.matt]

I can't deal with the asymmetry on the dial of the 5712 and it's like they threw a 5055 into a Nautilus case. In my humble opinion, the 5164 paired with a ceramic Daytona offers more variety. Question though: if the 5164 now sells for 50-60k and the Daytona can fetch as much as 25k, wouldn't you be able to trade it for a 5711? Unless, of course, you already own that watch

[watchbowl]

5712 for me

[ts3]

Originally Posted by ct.matt

I can't deal with the asymmetry on the dial of the 5712 and it's like they threw a 5055 into a Nautilus case. In my humble opinion, the 5164 paired with a ceramic Daytona offers more variety. Question though: if the 5164 now sells for 50-60k and the Daytona can fetch as much as 25k, wouldn't you be able to trade it for a 5711? Unless, of course, you already own that watch

Certainly wouldn't do the opposite and trade my blue 5711 into a 5164 + Daytona. That would mean giving up one watch I like a lot for one watch I don't like and one I like ok but where I'd miss the date...

[ct.matt]

Originally Posted by ts3

Certainly wouldn't do the opposite and trade my blue 5711 into a 5164 + Daytona. That would mean giving up one watch I like a lot for one watch I don't like and one I like ok but where I'd miss the date...

Luckily tastes differ and you're not the OP ;-) if we all had the same taste, this forum would get old very quickly. The Daytona is an easy weekend watch. No need to set any complication(s) after winding it.

Sent from my SM-G975U using Tapatalk

[HL65]

Originally Posted by RHIII

Assuming both at retail, it would be the 12 for me. Hands down my friend!!!


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

X2

[yoast]

5712

[ts3]

Originally Posted by ct.matt

Luckily tastes differ and you're not the OP ;-) if we all had the same taste, this forum would get old very quickly. The Daytona is an easy weekend watch. No need to set any complication(s) after winding it.

Sent from my SM-G975U using Tapatalk

Those left-side pushers on the 5164 are for me like the asymmetric dial of the 5712 for you. I just couldn't deal with them even if I wanted to have a travel time complication.

To each their own...