Best Vintage Rolex To Buy Today?

[rolexgirl1998]

Thinking it's time for me to get a new watch, I try to get 1-2 a year and I am having a hard time picking between the submariner 16610 or the day-date 18238. I know I know, both couldn't be more different. Anyone have any opinions about the watches themselves other than the fact that one is a daily watch and the other is a dress watch? Thanks in advance.

[Woody]

I think they are both "daily" watches. I personally prefer the 16610, but as you say that you usually buy 1-2 watches a year then surely the question is which do you buy first? They are at different price points so will likely depend on what watch becomes available first and what else you have in your collection. Good examples of the 16610 appear to be increasing in price fairly rapidly so that might be a factor to consider.....but you should buy what you like. Good luck with your decision.

[L.K Johnson]

Good choices! Both great watches but if I were you I would look at the 118238 instead, you will with that model get a heavier and full solid gold DD. It’s incredible well built!

[athom]

Best Vintage Rolex To Buy Today?

Depends what you have, depends what you like...

[Dan S]

Whatever will give you more joy? It's entirely a question of personal preference. Since those aren't really vintage IMO, they should be easy enough to find.

[baumare]

With 2 watches a year sounds like you're starting a collection, so depends of what you already have. 5 digits in great condition are not hard to find and both reference are a must in any collection.
It is a matter of personal preference and personally I will go for a nice gold Day-date now, perfect winter-time watch, and I will leave the Sub for the spring/summer

[harry in montreal]

buy the watch you love looking at, because you will be doing so ever hour. Buy the painting you love, not the one that matches your couch. Never buy a muscle car and settle with an autotragic transmission. Always go manual. Buy a smaller home nearer to bars and subways, rather than oversized house in the sticks. This is my unsolicited buying advice to all.

[Dan S]

Originally Posted by harry in montreal

buy the watch you love looking at, because you will be doing so ever hour. Buy the painting you love, not the one that matches your couch. Never buy a muscle car and settle with an autotragic transmission. Always go manual. Buy a smaller home nearer to bars and subways, rather than oversized house in the sticks. This is my unsolicited buying advice to all.

[baumare]

Originally Posted by harry in montreal

buy the watch you love looking at, because you will be doing so ever hour. Buy the painting you love, not the one that matches your couch. Never buy a muscle car and settle with an autotragic transmission. Always go manual. Buy a smaller home nearer to bars and subways, rather than oversized house in the sticks. This is my unsolicited buying advice to all.

I did everything right except the painting

[rolexgirl1998]

Very true, I have seen the 16610 increasing in price as well. I am even seeing some now selling over 10k. Might be a good idea to get this model now and before the prices keep increasing. Thanks for the input!

[rolexgirl1998]

Originally Posted by Woody

I think they are both "daily" watches. I personally prefer the 16610, but as you say that you usually buy 1-2 watches a year then surely the question is which do you buy first? They are at different price points so will likely depend on what watch becomes available first and what else you have in your collection. Good examples of the 16610 appear to be increasing in price fairly rapidly so that might be a factor to consider.....but you should buy what you like. Good luck with your decision.

Very true, I have seen the 16610 increasing in price as well. I am even seeing some now selling over 10k. Might be a good idea to get this model now and before the prices keep increasing. Thanks for the input!

[rolexgirl1998]

Originally Posted by baumare

With 2 watches a year sounds like you're starting a collection, so depends of what you already have. 5 digits in great condition are not hard to find and both reference are a must in any collection.
It is a matter of personal preference and personally I will go for a nice gold Day-date now, perfect winter-time watch, and I will leave the Sub for the spring/summer

That makes a lot of sense. I agree that the 18238 will be a better winter watch. I am more active in the summers so I know an all gold watch will scratch too much for me to feel safe wearing it all the time in the summer. Thanks so much!

[zapokee]

I'd go for the Day-Date. It's technically a dress watch but really goes with anything. I'm wearing my WG 1803 DD right now with a rugby shirt and sweatpants.

I wouldn't worry too much about scratching. I've had mine for almost 10 years, and the only scratches are on the crystal. And I don't baby it.

[rolexgirl1998]

Originally Posted by zapokee

I'd go for the Day-Date. It's technically a dress watch but really goes with anything. I'm wearing my WG 1803 DD right now with a rugby shirt and sweatpants.

I wouldn't worry too much about scratching. I've had mine for almost 10 years, and the only scratches are on the crystal. And I don't baby it.

That's actually great to know because I don't baby any of my watches! Thanks.

[harry in montreal]

I’ve never owned a gold watch. They are really heavy and fascinating

[zapokee]

Originally Posted by harry in montreal

I’ve never owned a gold watch. They are really heavy and fascinating

Gold isn't that heavy in the smaller volumes involved in a watch, particularly in the more subtle vintage 36 mm size of 1803s and the like.

Platinum is your really heavy MF, especially with the larger/thicker modern cases and bracelets. Try on a new platinum model at your AD. The weight is ridiculous.

[padi56]

Originally Posted by rolexgirl1998

Thinking it's time for me to get a new watch, I try to get 1-2 a year and I am having a hard time picking between the submariner 16610 or the day-date 18238. I know I know, both couldn't be more different. Anyone have any opinions about the watches themselves other than the fact that one is a daily watch and the other is a dress watch? Thanks in advance.

Would hardly call a 16610 0r 18238 vintage watches myself not a fan of precious metal watches so would choose the Sub.

[RHIII]

I would consider those two more neo-vintage pieces. Both are classics.

If you’re looking for a true vintage piece how about 1017 or a 1680? Super classy and elegant sport pieces. (same goes for the 1803 day date)


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[rootbeer7]

Apples and pears! 40mm Sports or 36mm Gold Dress Watch.
What does the rest of your collection look like?
If it’s missing a dressier piece, then go properly vintage 1803 (in white gold).

[Tools]

The "best" vintage watch to get is the one in the best condition for the money you are willing to pay.

As it ages you want to start on your best footing. You cannot re-do stuff that has already happened to a vintage piece very easily.

Model is up to individual preference

[harry in montreal]

Tools has great advice. Unless you are a real veteran, you should get one that keeps good time. If it’s your first vintage and the watch runs badly, losing it for repair is devastating. Now it takes me months to find the parts and get them going.

[rolexgirl1998]

Originally Posted by rootbeer7

Apples and pears! 40mm Sports or 36mm Gold Dress Watch.
What does the rest of your collection look like?
If it’s missing a dressier piece, then go properly vintage 1803 (in white gold).

I have dress watches and sport watches in my collection (16233, 16234, 126231, 116613LN). So, super unsure...

[suligeo]

The 1675 is the chameleon with all the different inlays.


https://www.instagram.com/vintage_georgex/

[MorningTundra]

Have you tried on the Sub? It's quite a heavy, chunky watch even on substantial wrists. If you have a pronounced wrist bone, it sits quite high on the wrist. The bracelet clasp is also rather substantial and I find myself snagging it on clothing (but not a problem if you live in a wet suit). I love my Subs and have owned several, but the 36mm DD is a much easier watch to wear every day.

[MrChamfers]

Which vintage Rolex?
All of them !

[Scatpackace]

After stumbling upon my Rolex commando a few days ago I think it’s pretty far up the list!

[ketonjo]

16800 might be a good choice. A bit underrated atm. Really good if you can find good deals on it.

Sent from my HD1900 using Tapatalk