tudor black bay for breitling heritage 42

[α-ψ!]

i would like your opinions for this trade, to give my tudor black bay for a new breitling superocean heritage 42!

[Thatguy]

I would not.

[vintagewaferthin]

I would keep the Tudor. In my opinion the Black Bay is way cooler than any Breitling.

[Monte Cristo]

This is a Rolex/Tudor forum, so I would think the majority will say "don't do it"....include me in that majority.

[watchnut73]

Black bay..!

[zeuloa]

Pics of the Breitling might help.

[TSW]

No for me.

[Cru Jones]

The Breitling isn't half bad looking on the mesh and the movements are a wash, so, why not? Plus, you'll have the date function (if that matters to you). Especially if the BB doesn't have the bracelet.

[watchupee]

[Polemic]

l'd keep Black Bay.

[Stoner319]

Black Bay pleez

[Solo118]

Originally Posted by α-ψ!

i would like your opinions for this trade, to give my tudor black bay for a new breitling superocean heritage 42!

I would keep the black bay. Not everybody knows what it is, but thats what is so great about it!

[roger0770]

bb all the way

[HogwldFLTR]

Choose which you like best imho. I like my Breitling Super Ocean XPlus 42mm and one of the things I like about the Tudor GranTour is that it is similar to the Breitlings your considering. The advantage the Breitling has is a date which the BBR doesn't! You might try asking the question in the Breitling sub forum.

[Star Ferry]

I vote for the Breitling. Looks more modern and finished IMO

[Forum-Dweller]

Maybe for a Navitimer but not that.

[Runfar]

simple- TUDOR!
its way more on the upward path than that Breitling

[uansari1]

I actually really like the lugs on the new Breitling Superocean Heritage II. I'd make that trade.

[slide13]

I'd go Breitling and put it on a leather strap.

I've had two Tudor BBs and they just didn't quite do it for me. I've never owned but always liked the look of that Breitling. I'm also a fan of leather straps and that is a great model to put on a leather strap. Not so much a fan of it on the mesh bracelet though so I guess depends on how you want to wear it.

[jason042779]

Depends which BB. Still think Breitling is getting the short end of the stick on this movement exchange program but the new SuperOcean Heritage IS good looking.

[AJM914]

Keep the tudor

[watchwatcher]

So...after 4 plus years, did the OP make a call?

[HogwldFLTR]

Originally Posted by watchwatcher

So...after 4 plus years, did the OP make a call?

WTH; how'd that show up for me? Definitely a dated email from right about the time the Breitlings came out. Funny I was thinking back about how I was considering them. Guilty as charged!!! Last activity was this month; judging from the lack of incoming thread, I'd guess not.

[Laszlo]

Originally Posted by watchwatcher

So...after 4 plus years, did the OP make a call?

[Polarbears]

I prefer the black Bay. That said I have two blue Bezel Black Bays in house and would love to trade for a superocean Heritage II especially in blue or white.