116500LN for 75% of a 15400OR. Would you?

[MiloDiThernan]

The Audemars Piguet is on a strap and is rose gold. I’ve gone with ratios, because cash ruins the conversation. But how much better is the AP than the 116500LN white dial? My 19cm wrist makes the Rolex small and my old eyes have a legibility problem. I’ve never experienced an AP, but have several Rolexes. I know it sounds like I’ve pretty much made my mind up, and I pretty much have, but I’d be interested in any views about the different experience. Which one would you go with and why?

[marc12]

yes
15400or all day on rubber strap

[bullies]

I most likely would, but it depends what else you have in your collection. If you have another Rolex then yes. If the 15400OR is going to be your one and only I'd be 50/50 on doing it.
Rolex is pretty hard to beat as a go anywhere do anything piece. From in the pool to out to dinner etc.
An APRO on leather can't do that.

I have a 15400st blue and it's pretty a awesome piece. Have thought many times about adding an OR.

(full transparency, I'm not a daytona fan)

[jgottsman11]

Prices across the board are stupid. I'd say the AP is a heck of a better watch.

[dpt.calvin]

Do it 100.

[justdate]

Royal Oak has to be on bracelet IMO, strap really doesn’t do it justice. Just what I think - having owned both variants.

[Solo118]

Only if it has the bracelet! On strap would pass even though the $ makes sense

[huncho]

wouldn't do it for a 15400OR on strap

[MiloDiThernan]

I agree with all these observations. And thank you for all of them. Luckily, I have Rolex and the only reason for chasing an APRO experience is bucket list curiosity. The joy I’ve had with the Rolexes has been very fully exploited and they are keepers. I just wonder if there’s a different variety of that joy with AP. And quite honestly this is my last chance, because I can’t really afford APRO at secondary prices. And I can’t get near an AD. And the way all watch prices are going, if I don’t commit now, then that’s that. I have tried a 15400ST on and I found the bracelet harsh and the steel all-in look a bit brutal. (And why buy APRO steel secondary when you can buy rose gold, albeit on strap, for pretty much the same price?) But I can see why most people emphasise the bracelet, even if it didn’t work for me, because it is utterly beautiful. (That said, the underside of my GMT jubilee bracelet feels very taut and slinky in an APRO way.) So the chance to get an RO, which doesn’t come along often with supply in the UK very limited, had to be taken. The Daytona has gone. I miss it. The RO arrives tomorrow. I’m tense. What if it wears badly? What if my intuition dislikes it? I’ll let you know once I’ve settled down with it because I can imagine that there are many Rolex aficionados who wonder about AP. So, good or bad, I’ll try and supply one person’s initial reaction. But most of all, thanks for the comments. It helps me think.

[kieselguhr]

I would buy I much prefer the RO to a steel Daytona. Even more so as the RO is PM

If you have a change of heart you could always trade back for what you want.

[Alliy]

Yes i would

[bullies]

Originally Posted by MiloDiThernan

I agree with all these observations. And thank you for all of them. Luckily, I have Rolex and the only reason for chasing an APRO experience is bucket list curiosity. The joy I’ve had with the Rolexes has been very fully exploited and they are keepers. I just wonder if there’s a different variety of that joy with AP. And quite honestly this is my last chance, because I can’t really afford APRO at secondary prices. And I can’t get near an AD. And the way all watch prices are going, if I don’t commit now, then that’s that. I have tried a 15400ST on and I found the bracelet harsh and the steel all-in look a bit brutal. (And why buy APRO steel secondary when you can buy rose gold, albeit on strap, for pretty much the same price?) But I can see why most people emphasise the bracelet, even if it didn’t work for me, because it is utterly beautiful. (That said, the underside of my GMT jubilee bracelet feels very taut and slinky in an APRO way.) So the chance to get an RO, which doesn’t come along often with supply in the UK very limited, had to be taken. The Daytona has gone. I miss it. The RO arrives tomorrow. I’m tense. What if it wears badly? What if my intuition dislikes it? I’ll let you know once I’ve settled down with it because I can imagine that there are many Rolex aficionados who wonder about AP. So, good or bad, I’ll try and supply one person’s initial reaction. But most of all, thanks for the comments. It helps me think.

Congrats, I'm sure you'll love it

[MP777]

I would keep the 116500

[huncho]

Originally Posted by MiloDiThernan

I agree with all these observations. And thank you for all of them. Luckily, I have Rolex and the only reason for chasing an APRO experience is bucket list curiosity. The joy I’ve had with the Rolexes has been very fully exploited and they are keepers. I just wonder if there’s a different variety of that joy with AP. And quite honestly this is my last chance, because I can’t really afford APRO at secondary prices. And I can’t get near an AD. And the way all watch prices are going, if I don’t commit now, then that’s that. I have tried a 15400ST on and I found the bracelet harsh and the steel all-in look a bit brutal. (And why buy APRO steel secondary when you can buy rose gold, albeit on strap, for pretty much the same price?) But I can see why most people emphasise the bracelet, even if it didn’t work for me, because it is utterly beautiful. (That said, the underside of my GMT jubilee bracelet feels very taut and slinky in an APRO way.) So the chance to get an RO, which doesn’t come along often with supply in the UK very limited, had to be taken. The Daytona has gone. I miss it. The RO arrives tomorrow. I’m tense. What if it wears badly? What if my intuition dislikes it? I’ll let you know once I’ve settled down with it because I can imagine that there are many Rolex aficionados who wonder about AP. So, good or bad, I’ll try and supply one person’s initial reaction. But most of all, thanks for the comments. It helps me think.

regardless of whether or not it's on bracelet ROs are on a different level. i have nothing against them on straps and i think they look good with them but most people emphasize the bracelet because it really gives the full experience. i don't think you'll be disappointed either way honestly, great watch either way. maybe if you keep it you'll decide to order the bracelet some day. post pics when it comes

[dmb359]

I would rather have a RO than the Daytona, but would only want a RO on bracelet.

[Tensai]

No way. But in full disclosure, I don’t enjoy the dated look of any AP.

[CoveWatch]

Oooof! tough one.. the Daytona is just so easy and worry free to wear without thought, while the RO is much nicer finished and spectacular to look at. While I do love the AP bracelet, i also dont mind it on a rubber strap for easy wear.

[AK797]

RO RG is superior, altho I'd get a rubber strap for it as it is sturdier.

[SS Oyster]

I would!


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[macrowatch]

If you love it, you can always add the bracelet later.

Enjoy the incoming! Even if it’s just a fling.

[jb335]

I love Royal Oaks and am lucky enough to own one but I prefer a Daytona 116500 over a RO on a strap.

[MiloDiThernan]

I’ll say nothing. I’d love to hear positive or negative comments. It all makes me think better about the way it makes me feel. Thank you I advance.

[bullies]

Originally Posted by MiloDiThernan

I’ll say nothing. I’d love to hear positive or negative comments. It all makes me think better about the way it makes me feel. Thank you I advance.

looks great, congrats!

[Jari from Finland]

But which one is better. There are many who says that AP has better finishing. But I was wondering how many of AP and Rolex wearers have ever opened the back case or have attended while watchmaker has opened the watch. In my opinion it depends on the current collection which one of those suits better in it. I expect that in the long run those both would be on your wish list regardless of your first choice.

[Al1969]

Originally Posted by MiloDiThernan

I’ll say nothing. I’d love to hear positive or negative comments. It all makes me think better about the way it makes me feel. Thank you I advance.

I also think it looks great on you. As others said, you can add the bracelet and take it to another “level” or wear it on rubber for a change. Congrats!